| 1B | Aaron Manes | Sr. | Trinity International University | |
| 2B | Jesus Castro | Sr. | Judson College | |
| SS | Brad Netzel | Sr. | University of St. Francis | |
| 3B | Nick Tantillo | Sr. | Saint Xavier University | |
| UIF | Steve Georgion | Sr. | Purdue University North Central | |
| OF | Jacob Pierce | Jr. | Purdue University North Central | |
| OF | Tony Testin | Fr. | Saint Xavier University | |
| OF | John Toussas | Sr. | Judson College | |
| OF | Andrew Van Byssum | Sr. | Trinity Christian College | |
| C | Dave Hardt | So. | Trinity International University | |
| C | Matt Kamp | Fr. | Trinity Christian College | |
| P | Steve Held | Jr. | Olivet Nazarene University | |
| P | Kyle Neubauer | Sr. | Judson College | |
| P | Ryan Quigley | Sr. | Saint Xavier University | |
| P | John Schenke | Sr. | Robert Morris College | |
| RP | Tom Albano | Jr. | Purdue University North Central | |
| DH | Ryan Buchler | Sr. | Saint Xavier University | |
| IF | Gary Bjorklund | Jr. | Robert Morris College |
| IF | Craig Buske | Jr. | Saint Xavier University |
| P/OF | Joel DeRuiter | Sr. | Trinity Christian College |
| P | Tim Gotzler | Sr. | Cardinal Stritch University |
| P | Erich Holsten | Jr. | Olivet Nazarene University |
| IF | Lacelle McKinley | Fr. | Calumet College of St. Joseph |
| P | Mike O'Leary | Jr. | Trinity International University |
| P | Branden Schombert | Fr. | Illinois Instittue of Technology |
| C | Zach Scipione | So. | Judson College |
| U | John Selman | So. | Purdue University North Central |
| P | Justin Vaughan | Sr. | University of St. Francis |
PLAYER OF THE YEAR:
Aaron Manes, Trinity International University
PITCHER OF THE YEAR:
Ryan Quigley, Saint Xavier University
FRESHMAN OF THE YEAR:
Matt Kamp, Trinity Christian College
COACH OF THE YEAR:
Matt Schans, Trinity Christian College
| IF | Gary Bjorklund | Jr. | Robert Morris College |
| IF | Craig Buske | Jr. | Saint Xavier University |
| P/OF | Joel DeRuiter | Sr. | Trinity Christian College |
| P | Tim Gotzler | Sr. | Cardinal Stritch University |
| P | Erich Holsten | Jr. | Olivet Nazarene University |
| IF | Lacelle McKinley | Fr. | Calumet College of St. Joseph |
| P | Mike O'Leary | Jr. | Trinity International University |
| P | Branden Schombert | Fr. | Illinois Instittue of Technology |
| C | Zach Scipione | So. | Judson College |
| U | John Selman | So. | Purdue University North Central |
| P | Justin Vaughan | Sr. | University of St. Francis |